| Penalties | Club | VS Club | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | Huddersfield | Halifax | 03-01-2009 | Match details |
| 6 | Macclesfield | Hull Ionians | 06-09-2008 | Match details |
| 6 | Darlington MP | Fylde | 07-03-2009 | Match details |
| 6 | Nuneaton | Harrogate | 04-10-2008 | Match details |
| 5 | Fylde | Nuneaton | 20-09-2008 | Match details |
| 5 | Halifax | Macclesfield | 21-02-2009 | Match details |
| 5 | Hull Ionians | Harrogate | 04-04-2009 | Match details |
| 5 | Kendal | Caldy | 20-12-2008 | Match details |
| 5 | Caldy | Fylde | 28-02-2009 | Match details |
| 5 | Preston Grasshoppers | Leicester Lions | 29-11-2008 | Match details |
| 3 | Bradford Bingley | Hull Ionians | 11-10-2008 | Match details |
| 3 | Loughborough Students | Nuneaton | 13-09-2008 | Match details |
| 3 | Harrogate | Bradford Bingley | 06-09-2008 | Match details |
| 3 | Leicester Lions | Harrogate | 24-01-2009 | Match details |
