| MD | Players | Club | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11-Apr-2009 |  David Scully | Sheffield Tigers | England | 07-Aug-1965 | 43(248) |
| 20-Dec-2008 | Luke Gross | Sheffield Tigers | United States | 21-Nov-1969 | 39(30) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Simon Bunting | Sheffield Tigers | England | 17-Sep-1970 | 38(207) |
| 18-Apr-2009 |  Mike Burnett | Morley | England | 09-Dec-1970 | 38(131) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Harry Toews | Sheffield Tigers | Canada | 07-Aug-1971 | 37(234) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Njike Tchakoute | Birkenhead Park | England | 23-Oct-1971 | 37(164) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Maea David | Hull | Other | 27-Feb-1972 | 37(30) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Jamie Connolly | West Hartlepool | * | 06-Feb-1973 | 36(64) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Dan Cook | Hull | England | 10-Sep-1974 | 34(207) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Ben Wade | Cleckheaton | England | 11-Sep-1974 | 34(206) |
| 21-Mar-2009 | Scott Benton | Morley | England | 08-Sep-1974 | 34(195) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Chris Stewart | West Hartlepool | Other | 13-Dec-1974 | 34(120) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Rob Hitchmough | West Park St Helens | England | 17-Dec-1975 | 33(109) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Chris Murphy | Hull | England | 02-Feb-1976 | 33(62) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Scott Plevey | Hull | England | 28-Sep-1976 | 32(188) |
| 21-Feb-2009 | Guy Hope | Beverley | England | 27-Oct-1976 | 32(117) |
| 11-Oct-2008 | Michael Wood | Hull | England | 15-Jul-1976 | 32(88) |
| 14-Feb-2009 | Nigel Douglas | Westoe | England | 25-Nov-1977 | 31(81) |
| 18-Apr-2009 | Leon Treco | Morley | England | 27-Sep-1978 | 30(204) |
| 29-Nov-2008 | Dave McCabe | Sheffield Tigers | Other | 07-Sep-1979 | 29(84) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Iain Robinson | West Hartlepool | Other | 07-Feb-1980 | 29(64) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Paul Vinnicombe | West Hartlepool | England | 03-Dec-1980 | 28(129) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Rob Devonshire | Hull | England | 13-Jan-1981 | 28(81) |
| 18-Apr-2009 | Kerry Wood | Westoe | England | 30-Jan-1981 | 28(78) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Iain Dixon | West Hartlepool | England | 04-Apr-1981 | 28(7) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Latu Makaafi | Hull | Tonga | 17-Aug-1981 | 27(230) |
| 24-Jan-2009 | Zak Hammond | Stockport | England | 09-Nov-1981 | 27(76) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Ryan de la Harpe | West Park St Helens | Namibia | 02-Sep-1982 | 26(215) |
| 18-Apr-2009 | Reuban Harvey | Stockport | New Zealand | 04-Oct-1982 | 26(197) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Shaun Richardson | Darlington | England | 11-Oct-1982 | 26(169) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Gareth Kerr | West Hartlepool | Other | 11-Jul-1983 | 25(275) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Gareth Morley | Sheffield Tigers | England | 25-May-1984 | 24(321) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Alex Piercey | Hull | England | 03-Jul-1984 | 24(275) |
| 11-Oct-2008 | James Stannard | Morley | England | 08-Aug-1984 | 24(64) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Sione Onesi | Hull | Other | 17-Jun-1985 | 23(291) |
| 18-Apr-2009 | James Fitzpatrick | Westoe | England | 06-Jul-1987 | 21(287) |
| 18-Apr-2009 | Ashely Moeke | Westoe | New Zealand | 09-Mar-1988 | 21(40) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Aaron Myers | West Hartlepool | England | 30-May-1988 | 20(316) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | James Cameron | Hull | England | 19-Oct-1988 | 20(167) |
| 15-Nov-2008 | Mateo Malupo | Hull | Tonga | 07-Jul-1988 | 20(131) |
| 18-Apr-2009 | Gavin Charlton | Westoe | England | 03-Feb-1989 | 20(74) |
| 18-Apr-2009 | Tom Cruse | Stockport | England | 30-Mar-1989 | 20(19) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Dominic Parsons | Sheffield Tigers | England | 19-Apr-1989 | 19(357) |
| 14-Mar-2009 | Nick Brocklehurst | Cleckheaton | England | 29-Sep-1989 | 19(166) |
| 29-Nov-2008 | Mohammed Mustafa | Middlesbrough | England | 20-Feb-1990 | 18(283) |
| 21-Mar-2009 | Max Alderson | Middlesbrough | England | 07-Aug-1990 | 18(227) |
| 21-Mar-2009 | Carl Kirwan | Middlesbrough | England | 21-Mar-1991 | 18(1) |
| 31-Jan-2009 | Peter Homan | Middlesbrough | England | 25-Jul-1991 | 17(191) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date of birth,
A(D) = Age(days).