| Penalties | Club | VS Club | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Rugby Lions | Luctonians | 12-11-2005 | Match details |
| 5 | Scunthorpe | Luctonians | 25-03-2006 | Match details |
| 5 | Bedford Athletic | Dunstablians | 10-12-2005 | Match details |
| 4 | Dudley Kingwinsford | Luton | 19-11-2005 | Match details |
| 4 | Luctonians | Bromsgrove | 11-02-2006 | Match details |
| 4 | Market Bosworth | Dudley Kingwinsford | 28-01-2006 | Match details |
| 3 | Luton | Market Bosworth | 25-03-2006 | Match details |
| 3 | Burton | Kettering | 03-12-2005 | Match details |
| 3 | Dunstablians | Market Bosworth | 18-02-2006 | Match details |
| 3 | Kettering | Rugby Lions | 17-12-2005 | Match details |
| 2 | Walsall | Market Bosworth | 10-09-2005 | Match details |
| 2 | Bromsgrove | Dunstablians | 03-12-2005 | Match details |
