| SD | Players | Club | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 02-Mar-2013 |  Matt Long | Birmingham Solihull | England | 25-May-1973 | 39(282) |
| 10-Nov-2012 |  Scott Benton | Huddersfield | England | 08-Sep-1974 | 38(64) |
| 27-Apr-2013 | Lome Fa'atau | Westoe | Samoa | 23-Oct-1975 | 37(187) |
| 04-May-2013 |  Stephen Johnson | Hull Ionians | England | 07-Mar-1977 | 36(58) |
| 10-Nov-2012 | Gregor Hayter | Sheffield Tigers | Scotland | 13-Aug-1976 | 36(89) |
| 10-Nov-2012 | Chris Murphy | Hull | England | 02-Feb-1976 | 36(282) |
| 02-Mar-2013 | Junior Fagalilo | Darlington MP | Other | 19-Sep-1977 | 35(165) |
| 30-Mar-2013 |  Craig Aikman | Preston Grasshoppers | England | 13-Feb-1978 | 35(46) |
| 09-Feb-2013 | Toby Wilson | Bromsgrove | Other | 11-Sep-1977 | 35(152) |
| 27-Apr-2013 | Anthony Marfell | Luctonians | England | 16-Oct-1978 | 34(194) |
SD = Scored date ,
DOB = Date of birth ,
A(D) = Age(days) .