| Penalties | Players | VS Club | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | John Pemberthy | Hereford | 07-11-2009 | Match details |
| 3 | John Pemberthy | Bromsgrove | 31-10-2009 | Match details |
| 3 | John Pemberthy | Kenilworth | 28-11-2009 | Match details |
| 2 | Tim Jones | Luctonians | 12-09-2009 | Match details |
| 2 | Tom Bridgman | Luctonians | 12-12-2009 | Match details |
| 1 | Tim Jones | Longton | 05-09-2009 | Match details |
| 1 | Tim Jones | Newport (Salop) | 26-09-2009 | Match details |
| 1 | Tim Jones | Peterborough | 03-10-2009 | Match details |
| 1 | Tom Bridgman | Ampthill | 17-10-2009 | Match details |
| 1 | John Pemberthy | Hinckley | 14-11-2009 | Match details |
| 1 | Bruce Keir | Luton | 23-01-2010 | Match details |
