| MD | Players | Club | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16-Sep-2023 |  Gavin Woods | Lymm | England | 03-Sep-1982 | 41(13) |
| 09-Sep-2023 |  Matthew Challinor | Rotherham Titans | England | 14-Feb-1984 | 39(208) |
| 09-Sep-2023 |  Robert Baldwin | Wharfedale | England | 20-Jul-1985 | 38(51) |
| 09-Sep-2023 |  Chris Wearmouth | Tynedale | England | 13-Apr-1986 | 37(149) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Toby Williams | Leeds Tykes | England | 15-May-1986 | 37(124) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Adam Lewis | Fylde | England | 03-Mar-1987 | 36(190) |
| 09-Sep-2023 |  Alex Forth | Hull Ionians | England | 27-Apr-1987 | 36(135) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Tomasi Tanumi | Rotherham Titans | Other | 18-May-1987 | 36(121) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Tevita Halaifonua | Hull | Tonga | 05-Jul-1987 | 36(66) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | David Fairbrother | Fylde | England | 28-Sep-1987 | 35(354) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Ryan Burrows | Sheffield | England | 25-Apr-1988 | 35(144) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Jacob Brady | Leeds Tykes | England | 30-Sep-1988 | 34(351) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Graeme Dunn | Tynedale | England | 11-Apr-1989 | 34(151) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Dominic Parsons | Sheffield | England | 19-Apr-1989 | 34(150) |
| 09-Sep-2023 |  Jason Moss | Otley | England | 30-May-1989 | 34(102) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Luke Thundercliffe | Hull Ionians | England | 21-Jul-1989 | 34(50) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Thomas Calladine | Sheffield Tigers | England | 02-Aug-1989 | 34(38) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Matthew Smith | Rotherham Titans | England | 26-Oct-1989 | 33(325) |
| 02-Sep-2023 | Alexander Campbell | Hull Ionians | England | 27-Dec-1989 | 33(249) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Joe Makin | Hull Ionians | England | 17-Mar-1990 | 33(183) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Gareth Denman | Rotherham Titans | England | 12-Nov-1990 | 32(308) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Laurence Cowan | Rotherham Titans | England | 28-Aug-1991 | 32(19) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Jack Bergmanas | Rotherham Titans | England | 26-Oct-1991 | 31(318) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Lloyd Hayes | Rotherham Titans | England | 11-Nov-1991 | 31(310) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Joe Rowntree | Otley | England | 01-Feb-1992 | 31(220) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Adam Malthouse | Otley | England | 10-Mar-1992 | 31(183) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Alastair Sutherland | Lymm | England | 21-Mar-1992 | 31(178) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Daniel Rundle | Rotherham Titans | England | 30-Jul-1992 | 31(47) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Sam Wilson | Hull Ionians | England | 15-Oct-1992 | 30(336) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Jean Baptiste Bruzuler | Rotherham Titans | France | 15-Oct-1992 | 30(336) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Jordan Dorrington | Fylde | England | 02-Sep-1993 | 30(14) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Lewis Minikin | Hull Ionians | England | 13-Sep-1993 | 30(3) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Luke Cole | Rotherham Titans | England | 07-Nov-1993 | 29(313) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Alex Heard | Hull | England | 08-Nov-1993 | 29(305) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Jake Armstrong | Wharfedale | England | 17-Mar-1994 | 29(176) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Rupert Kay | Rotherham Titans | England | 03-Jan-1995 | 28(249) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Liam Parfitt | Huddersfield | England | 16-Sep-1995 | 27(358) |
| 02-Sep-2023 | Dan Preston-Routledge | Otley | England | 27-Oct-1995 | 27(310) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Lewis Workman | Huddersfield | England | 08-Nov-1995 | 27(305) |
| 02-Sep-2023 | Jonathan Coser | Otley | England | 06-Nov-1995 | 27(300) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Charles Capps | Rotherham Titans | England | 08-Jun-1997 | 26(93) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Callum Bustin | Rotherham Titans | England | 12-Aug-1997 | 26(28) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Sam Pocklington | Hull Ionians | England | 25-Sep-1998 | 24(356) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | John Okafor | Rotherham Titans | England | 08-Oct-1998 | 24(343) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Callum Morris | Lymm | Wales | 20-Jun-1999 | 24(88) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Sam Wager | Sheffield Tigers | England | 01-Nov-1999 | 23(312) |
| 16-Sep-2023 | Alex Pleasants | Rotherham Titans | England | 20-Sep-2000 | 22(361) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | Oscar Caudle | Tynedale | England | 14-Oct-2000 | 22(330) |
| 09-Sep-2023 | James Magee | Leeds Tykes | England | 11-Apr-2001 | 22(151) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date of birth,
A(D) = Age(days).