| MD | Players | Club | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 06-Apr-2019 |  Stephen Johnson | Hull Ionians | England | 07-Mar-1977 | 42(30) |
| 06-Apr-2019 |  Roderick McNaughton | South Leicester | England | 29-Mar-1978 | 41(8) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Shaun Murray | South Leicester | Other | 14-Jun-1978 | 40(296) |
| 15-Dec-2018 |  Rod Petty | Stourbridge | England | 13-Feb-1979 | 39(306) |
| 08-Dec-2018 | Michael Penn | Stourbridge | England | 07-Aug-1979 | 39(124) |
| 30-Mar-2019 | Scott Hamilton | Hinckley | New Zealand | 04-Mar-1980 | 39(26) |
| 19-Jan-2019 |  Paul Arnold | Preston Grasshoppers | England | 30-Jul-1980 | 38(173) |
| 09-Mar-2019 | Andy Phillips | Peterborough | England | 04-Nov-1981 | 37(125) |
| 16-Mar-2019 | Adam Blades | Huddersfield | England | 22-Dec-1981 | 37(84) |
| 02-Mar-2019 | Mark Chivers | Huddersfield | England | 09-Mar-1982 | 36(358) |
| 02-Mar-2019 | Michael Holford | South Leicester | England | 11-Aug-1982 | 36(203) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Chris Briers | Fylde | England | 01-Sep-1983 | 35(218) |
| 15-Sep-2018 | Matt Price | South Leicester | England | 23-Feb-1983 | 35(205) |
| 02-Feb-2019 | Alex Loney | Fylde | England | 29-Sep-1983 | 35(127) |
| 30-Mar-2019 | Sean Green | Chester | England | 07-Feb-1984 | 35(52) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Tom Foden | Chester | England | 03-Mar-1984 | 35(34) |
| 30-Mar-2019 | Martin Wolfenden | South Leicester | Zimbabwe | 04-May-1984 | 34(330) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Colin Campbell | Chester | England | 24-Jun-1984 | 34(286) |
| 23-Mar-2019 | Ross White | Chester | England | 04-Sep-1984 | 34(200) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | David Laverick | Hull Ionians | England | 20-Mar-1985 | 34(17) |
| 06-Oct-2018 |  Ben Steele | Otley | England | 24-Oct-1984 | 33(347) |
| 26-Jan-2019 | Adam Thomas | Hull Ionians | England | 23-Apr-1985 | 33(278) |
| 06-Apr-2019 |  Robert Baldwin | Wharfedale | England | 20-Jul-1985 | 33(260) |
| 08-Sep-2018 |  James Clark | Tynedale | England | 01-Feb-1985 | 33(219) |
| 06-Apr-2019 |  Steve Collins | Sedgley Park | England | 16-Sep-1985 | 33(202) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Simon Willett | Otley | England | 24-Sep-1985 | 33(194) |
| 01-Sep-2018 |  Chris Townsend | Macclesfield | England | 06-Mar-1985 | 33(179) |
| 12-Jan-2019 | Ben Foden | Chester | England | 22-Jul-1985 | 33(174) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Tom Cheney | South Leicester | Other | 29-Oct-1985 | 33(159) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Mark Pease | Huddersfield | England | 02-Jan-1986 | 33(94) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Llyr Griffiths | Stourbridge | England | 11-Jan-1986 | 33(85) |
| 26-Jan-2019 | Laurence Sanderson | Otley | England | 07-Nov-1985 | 33(80) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Chris Wearmouth | Tynedale | England | 13-Apr-1986 | 32(358) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Matt Riley | Sedgley Park | England | 18-Jun-1986 | 32(292) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Nicholas Sharpe | Huddersfield | England | 14-Jul-1986 | 32(266) |
| 23-Feb-2019 | Lee Smith | Huddersfield | England | 08-Aug-1986 | 32(199) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Chris Johnson | Huddersfield | England | 02-Oct-1986 | 32(186) |
| 08-Sep-2018 | Peter Rees | Chester | England | 09-Mar-1986 | 32(183) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Mark Wigham | Hull Ionians | England | 19-Nov-1986 | 32(138) |
| 17-Nov-2018 | Jake Carter | Peterborough | Portugal | 11-Sep-1986 | 32(67) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Adam Lewis | Fylde | England | 03-Mar-1987 | 32(34) |
| 23-Mar-2019 | Joe Graham | Otley | England | 03-Jun-1987 | 31(294) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | James Fitzpatrick | Preston Grasshoppers | England | 06-Jul-1987 | 31(275) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Adam Howard | Preston Grasshoppers | England | 22-Jul-1987 | 31(258) |
| 06-Apr-2019 | Sam Moss | Macclesfield | England | 24-Jul-1987 | 31(257) |
| 29-Sep-2018 | Chris Cutts | Peterborough | England | 23-Jan-1987 | 31(249) |
| 09-Feb-2019 | Craig Ross | Chester | England | 19-Jul-1987 | 31(205) |
| 15-Dec-2018 | Jon Wild | Fylde | England | 06-Jun-1987 | 31(192) |
| 29-Sep-2018 | Alex Forth | Hull Ionians | England | 27-Apr-1987 | 31(155) |
| 24-Nov-2018 | David Fairbrother | Fylde | England | 28-Sep-1987 | 31(57) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date of birth,
A(D) = Age(days).