| MD | Players | Club | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 04-Apr-2009 |  Gregg Botterman | Old Albanian | England | 03-Mar-1968 | 41(32) |
| 13-Sep-2008 |  Brendan Tracey | Portsmouth | * | 25-May-1973 | 35(112) |
| 28-Mar-2009 |  Kern Yates | Jersey | England | 12-Feb-1974 | 35(45) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Matt Allen | Luton | England | 28-Feb-1974 | 35(36) |
| 11-Oct-2008 | Henry Whitford | Old Albanian | England | 07-Mar-1974 | 34(219) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Alex Bennett | Old Albanian | Wales | 18-Jan-1975 | 34(77) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Hendry Rheeders | Jersey | South Africa | 21-May-1975 | 33(312) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Nick Peters | Luton | Other | 02-Jan-1976 | 33(93) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Paul Gustard | Old Albanian | England | 02-Feb-1976 | 33(55) |
| 31-Jan-2009 | Kenni Barrett | Shelford | England | 10-Apr-1976 | 32(296) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Andy Davey | Luton | Other | 24-Oct-1976 | 32(155) |
| 07-Mar-2009 | James Brownrigg | Barnes | England | 04-Jun-1977 | 31(276) |
| 29-Nov-2008 | Tom Archer | Barnes | England | 31-Mar-1977 | 31(244) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Matthew Clarke | Barnes | England | 05-Oct-1977 | 31(175) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Tom Radbourne | Portsmouth | England | 16-Dec-1977 | 31(117) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Graeme Frith | Portsmouth | Other | 03-May-1979 | 29(344) |
| 20-Dec-2008 | Nathan Kemp | Jersey | New Zealand | 19-Jan-1979 | 29(336) |
| 20-Dec-2008 | Greg Howe | Tring | Other | 12-Mar-1979 | 29(284) |
| 25-Oct-2008 | Liam Cassidy | Luton | Other | 06-Mar-1979 | 29(234) |
| 18-Apr-2009 | Ian Hardcastle | Hertford | Other | 06-Dec-1979 | 29(134) |
| 14-Mar-2009 | Ross Blake | Barnes | Scotland | 29-Dec-1979 | 29(76) |
| 04-Oct-2008 | Robert White | Portsmouth | England | 19-Nov-1979 | 28(320) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Simon Givens | Barnes | England | 23-May-1980 | 28(309) |
| 14-Feb-2009 | James Ball | Shelford | England | 17-Apr-1980 | 28(303) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Chris Rainbow | Hertford | Other | 12-Aug-1980 | 28(235) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Dafydd Lewis | Shelford | Other | 21-Mar-1981 | 28(14) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Graham Bell | Jersey | Scotland | 23-Apr-1981 | 27(339) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | John Brennan | Jersey | Jersey | 19-May-1981 | 27(320) |
| 21-Mar-2009 | Scott Walker | Luton | Other | 07-Jun-1981 | 27(287) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Richard Gregg | Old Albanian | England | 21-Dec-1981 | 27(104) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Ali Buchanan | Barnes | Other | 17-Jan-1982 | 27(70) |
| 14-Mar-2009 | Mike Ormesher | Luton | England | 28-Jan-1982 | 27(45) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Tony Begovich | Shelford | Other | 09-May-1982 | 26(331) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Graham Butterworth | Portsmouth | England | 28-Aug-1982 | 26(227) |
| 14-Mar-2009 | Stephen Gray | Luton | Other | 21-Aug-1982 | 26(206) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Dominic Jones | Shelford | England | 02-Oct-1982 | 26(185) |
| 14-Feb-2009 | Mark Gray | Luton | Other | 21-Aug-1982 | 26(178) |
| 24-Jan-2009 | William Temperley | Luton | England | 16-Sep-1982 | 26(131) |
| 11-Oct-2008 | Scott Hills | Luton | Other | 19-Sep-1982 | 26(23) |
| 20-Sep-2008 | Michael Adeniya | Luton | Other | 08-Oct-1982 | 25(348) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Josh Clements | Barnes | Other | 05-Jul-1983 | 25(267) |
| 14-Mar-2009 | Dwayne Duffy | Luton | England | 16-Jul-1983 | 25(242) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Warren Gower | Barnes | England | 02-Aug-1983 | 25(239) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Liam Lancaster | Luton | Other | 19-Aug-1983 | 25(222) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | John Robinson | Luton | Other | 21-Jun-1984 | 24(287) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Mitch Burton | Jersey | England | 25-Nov-1984 | 24(130) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Laurence Alden | Luton | England | 15-Feb-1985 | 24(48) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | James Armitage | Shelford | England | 22-Jul-1985 | 23(256) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Thomas Turner | Jersey | England | 31-Aug-1985 | 23(216) |
| 07-Mar-2009 | James Lumby | Barnes | England | 03-Sep-1985 | 23(185) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date of birth,
A(D) = Age(days).