| MD | Players | Club | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 02-Mar-2019 |  Alfie Petch | Taunton | England | 21-Dec-0199 | 1819(72) |
| 21-Jan-2023 |  Adrian Olver | Stourbridge | England | 02-Jun-1969 | 53(233) |
| 25-Apr-2015 | Mark Manton | Taunton | England | 19-Jun-1967 | 47(311) |
| 28-Mar-2015 | Josh Taylor | Shelford | England | 06-Jan-1970 | 45(81) |
| 07-Mar-2015 | David Hilton | Dings Crusaders | Scotland | 03-Apr-1970 | 44(338) |
| 04-Feb-2023 | Shaun Murray | Leicester Lions | England | 14-Jun-1978 | 44(235) |
| 11-Sep-2021 | Roderick McNaughton | Leicester Lions | England | 29-Mar-1978 | 43(167) |
| 01-Oct-2022 | Michael Penn | Stourbridge | England | 07-Aug-1979 | 43(56) |
| 11-Dec-2010 |  Gregg Botterman | Old Albanian | England | 03-Mar-1968 | 42(283) |
| 12-Apr-2008 |  Andrew Deacon | Cinderford | England | 31-Jul-1965 | 42(256) |
| 30-Apr-2016 |  Kris Chesney | Southend | England | 02-Mar-1974 | 42(60) |
| 18-Dec-2021 | Paul Fincken | Clifton | England | 30-Jan-1980 | 41(323) |
| 14-Apr-2001 |  Graham Dawe | Plymouth Albion | England | 04-Sep-1959 | 41(223) |
| 19-Mar-2022 |  Kenneth Dowding | Worthing Raiders | England | 17-Dec-1980 | 41(92) |
| 27-Apr-2019 |  Palepoi Nonu | Redruth | New Zealand | 12-Feb-1978 | 41(74) |
| 19-Feb-2005 | Neil Douch | Redruth | England | 15-Dec-1963 | 41(67) |
| 14-Sep-2013 | Darren Crompton | Hartpury College | England | 12-Sep-1972 | 41(2) |
| 30-Mar-2002 |  Paul Essenhigh | Blackheath | Other | 19-Apr-1961 | 40(345) |
| 22-Jan-2022 | Waylon Gasson | Dings Crusaders | England | 25-Jun-1981 | 40(211) |
| 23-Jan-2016 | Mike McFarlane | Dorking | England | 20-Aug-1975 | 40(156) |
| 13-Feb-2010 |  David Essian | Ealing Trailfinders | Other | 11-Sep-1969 | 40(155) |
| 24-Jan-2015 |  Duncan Bell | Lydney | England | 01-Oct-1974 | 40(115) |
| 04-Jan-2003 |  Richard Hennah | Westcombe Park | * | 11-Oct-1962 | 40(85) |
| 29-Apr-2017 | Ross Denton | Clifton | England | 05-Feb-1977 | 40(83) |
| 30-Mar-2018 |  James Hadfield | Henley Hawks | England | 02-Feb-1978 | 40(56) |
| 02-Sep-2000 | Stuart Roberts | Clifton | England | 20-Aug-1960 | 40(13) |
| 13-Apr-2013 | Keith Brooking | Taunton | England | 07-May-1973 | 39(342) |
| 26-Apr-2014 | Terry Fanolua | Hartpury College | Samoa | 03-Jul-1974 | 39(298) |
| 28-Apr-2012 | Jon Phillips | Old Albanian | England | 16-Aug-1972 | 39(256) |
| 26-Apr-2014 | Maama Molitika | Ampthill | Tonga | 26-Aug-1974 | 39(244) |
| 01-May-2010 |  Chris Ritchie | Rosslyn Park | England | 03-Nov-1970 | 39(180) |
| 22-Feb-2014 | Altan Ozdemir | Taunton | England | 03-Sep-1974 | 39(173) |
| 23-Apr-2016 | James Shanahan | Old Albanian | England | 12-Feb-1977 | 39(71) |
| 28-Jan-2023 | Alex Chase | Hornets | England | 20-Nov-1983 | 39(70) |
| 19-Feb-2011 | Mark Regan | Clifton | England | 28-Jan-1972 | 39(23) |
| 27-Apr-2019 | Huw Bevan | Barnes | England | 14-May-1980 | 38(348) |
| 30-Apr-2016 | Jeremy Flynn | Rams | England | 23-May-1977 | 38(343) |
| 02-Mar-2019 |  Stewart Pearl | Birmingham Solihull | England | 08-Jun-1980 | 38(267) |
| 26-Apr-2014 | Chris Fortey | Hartpury College | England | 25-Aug-1975 | 38(245) |
| 14-Sep-2013 | James Luck | Dings Crusaders | Other | 18-Mar-1975 | 38(181) |
| 18-Apr-2009 | Dylan Raubenheimer | Havant | Other | 15-Nov-1970 | 38(155) |
| 03-Dec-2022 | Luke Arscott | Dings Crusaders | England | 07-Jul-1984 | 38(149) |
| 21-Mar-2009 | Rob Matthews | Havant | Other | 12-Nov-1970 | 38(130) |
| 19-Apr-2008 | Eddie Smith | Clifton | * | 15-Dec-1969 | 38(126) |
| 26-Apr-2014 | Nathan Thomas | Hartpury College | 22-Jan-1976 | 38(95) | |
| 11-Dec-2010 | Howard Parr | Henley Hawks | England | 01-Nov-1972 | 38(40) |
| 01-Apr-2017 | Makulusio Koroiyadi | Bury St Edmunds | Other | 01-Mar-1979 | 38(32) |
| 18-Feb-2006 | Martin Roberts | Cinderford | England | 21-Jan-1968 | 38(29) |
| 28-Apr-2018 | Lee Starling | London Irish WG | England | 02-Apr-1980 | 38(26) |
| 12-Apr-2014 | Kenni Barrett | Ampthill | England | 10-Apr-1976 | 38(2) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date of birth,
A(D) = Age(days).