| MD | Players | Club | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26-Feb-2010 |  Graham Dawe | Plymouth Albion | England | 04-Sep-1959 | 50(176) |
| 25-Jan-2011 | Mark Manton | Plymouth Albion | England | 19-Jun-1967 | 43(221) |
| 28-Nov-2009 |  Richard Jones | Cardiff Blues | Wales | 27-Jan-1967 | 42(306) |
| 05-Apr-2013 |  Owain Lloyd | Bridgend | Other | 26-Sep-1970 | 42(192) |
| 21-Jan-2017 | Paul Tupai | Bedford Blues | Samoa | 16-Sep-1974 | 42(128) |
| 27-Feb-2011 |  Ngazu Tau | Birmingham Solihull | Tonga | 15-Jan-1969 | 42(43) |
| 29-Nov-2014 | Andrew B Jones | Carmarthen QUins | Wales | 17-Nov-1973 | 41(12) |
| 11-Oct-2014 |  Glen Kenworthy | Doncaster Knights | England | 15-Mar-1974 | 40(210) |
| 26-Feb-2010 | Nat Saumi | Plymouth Albion | Fiji | 03-Sep-1970 | 39(177) |
| 20-Oct-2013 | Tom Weir | Gala | Scotland | 11-Jul-1974 | 39(102) |
| 23-Feb-2013 | Richard Morris | Aberavon | Wales | 14-Feb-1974 | 39(10) |
| 07-May-2011 |  Darren Crompton | Bristol Bears | England | 12-Sep-1972 | 38(237) |
| 31-Mar-2017 |  Mark Bright | Ealing Trailfinders | New Zealand | 29-Sep-1978 | 38(184) |
| 18-Jan-2014 |  Ben Evans | Moseley | Wales | 31-Jul-1975 | 38(172) |
| 13-Mar-2016 |  Alan Paver | Cornish Pirates | England | 28-Nov-1977 | 38(106) |
| 19-Jan-2014 | Opeta Palepoi | Gala | Samoa | 02-Dec-1975 | 38(49) |
| 01-Feb-2013 | Deri Mattravers | Bedwas | Wales | 26-Mar-1975 | 37(313) |
| 25-Oct-2014 | James Shanahan | Plymouth Albion | England | 12-Feb-1977 | 37(255) |
| 13-Dec-2014 | Taufa'ao Filise | Pontypridd | Tonga | 26-May-1977 | 37(201) |
| 07-Apr-2013 | Roy Winters | Bristol Bears | England | 13-Dec-1975 | 37(116) |
| 08-Feb-2011 | Nick Walshe | Bedford Blues | England | 01-Nov-1973 | 37(99) |
| 20-Mar-2016 | Dean Schofield | Leeds Tykes | England | 19-Jan-1979 | 37(61) |
| 29-Nov-2014 | Michael Swift | Connacht | Ireland | 18-Oct-1977 | 37(42) |
| 12-Jan-2013 | Nathan Strong | Aberavon | Wales | 20-Jan-1976 | 36(358) |
| 05-Mar-2011 |  Tevita Taumoepeau | Worcester Warriors | Tonga | 16-May-1974 | 36(293) |
| 12-Mar-2010 | Mike Harris | Aberavon | Wales | 30-May-1973 | 36(286) |
| 19-Dec-2015 | Laurie McGlone | Cornish Pirates | New Zealand | 26-Mar-1979 | 36(268) |
| 18-Jan-2013 | Keni Fisilau | Plymouth Albion | Tonga | 04-May-1976 | 36(259) |
| 05-Mar-2011 |  Malcolm O'Kelly | Leinster | Ireland | 19-Jul-1974 | 36(229) |
| 21-Nov-2009 | Matt Long | Birmingham Solihull | England | 25-May-1973 | 36(180) |
| 23-Jan-2016 | Michael Penn | Moseley | England | 07-Aug-1979 | 36(169) |
| 27-Feb-2011 |  Ben Wade | Rotherham Titans | England | 11-Sep-1974 | 36(169) |
| 18-Jan-2014 |  Sonny Parker | London Welsh | Wales | 27-Aug-1977 | 36(144) |
| 13-Dec-2014 |  Ben Prescott | London Scottish | Scotland | 31-Jul-1978 | 36(135) |
| 17-Dec-2016 |  Peter Edwards | Scarlets | Wales | 12-Aug-1980 | 36(127) |
| 21-Nov-2015 | James Pritchard | Bedford Blues | Canada | 21-Jul-1979 | 36(123) |
| 14-Feb-2010 |  Tommy Hayes | Coventry | Cook Island | 13-Dec-1973 | 36(63) |
| 21-Oct-2016 |  Regan King | Jersey | New Zealand | 02-Oct-1980 | 36(19) |
| 19-Jan-2014 | Palepoi Nonu | Plymouth Albion | New Zealand | 12-Feb-1978 | 35(342) |
| 25-Oct-2014 | Mike Powell | Moseley | Wales | 23-Nov-1978 | 35(337) |
| 26-Feb-2011 | Cameron Murray | Melrose | Scotland | 31-Mar-1975 | 35(333) |
| 24-Jan-2015 |  Donncha O'Callaghan | Munster | Ireland | 24-Mar-1979 | 35(307) |
| 15-Dec-2012 | Gareth Wyatt | Pontypridd | Wales | 04-Mar-1977 | 35(287) |
| 06-Mar-2010 | Kevin Maggs | Rotherham Titans | Ireland | 03-Jun-1974 | 35(277) |
| 09-Jan-2011 | Russell Earnshaw | Birmingham Solihull | England | 08-Apr-1975 | 35(277) |
| 21-Jan-2017 | Richard List | Doncaster Knights | England | 01-May-1981 | 35(266) |
| 13-Dec-2014 | Neil Best | London Scottish | Ireland | 03-Apr-1979 | 35(255) |
| 13-Jan-2017 | Colin Quigley | Doncaster Knights | Scotland | 14-May-1981 | 35(245) |
| 23-Apr-2011 | Oriol Ripol | Worcester Warriors | Spain | 06-Sep-1975 | 35(230) |
| 10-Apr-2016 | Chris Jones | Leeds Tykes | England | 24-Aug-1980 | 35(230) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date of birth,
A(D) = Age(days).