| MD | Players | Club | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20-Sep-2008 |  Graham Dawe | Plymouth Albion | England | 04-Sep-1959 | 49(17) |
| 28-Mar-2009 |  Tim Fourie | Sedgley Park | England | 12-Mar-1968 | 41(16) |
| 04-Apr-2009 |  Ngazu Tau | Doncaster Knights | Tonga | 15-Jan-1969 | 40(79) |
| 15-Nov-2008 | Nat Saumi | Plymouth Albion | Fiji | 03-Sep-1970 | 38(74) |
| 25-Apr-2009 |  Howard Parr | Otley | England | 01-Nov-1972 | 36(175) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Kristyan Fullman | Otley | England | 07-Dec-1972 | 36(139) |
| 25-Apr-2009 |  Chris Budgen | Exeter Chiefs | England | 21-Mar-1973 | 36(35) |
| 25-Apr-2009 |  Jason Strange | Leeds Tykes | Wales | 08-Oct-1973 | 35(200) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Mark Fatialofa | Exeter Chiefs | * | 12-Nov-1973 | 35(151) |
| 21-Mar-2009 | Nick Walshe | Bedford Blues | England | 01-Nov-1973 | 35(141) |
| 21-Mar-2009 |  Tommy Hayes | Coventry | Cook Island | 13-Dec-1973 | 35(99) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Henry Paul | Leeds Tykes | England | 10-Feb-1974 | 35(75) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Glen Kenworthy | Doncaster Knights | England | 15-Mar-1974 | 35(42) |
| 04-Apr-2009 | Ben Breeze | Exeter Chiefs | England | 08-Apr-1974 | 34(362) |
| 25-Apr-2009 |  Kevin Maggs | Rotherham Titans | Ireland | 03-Jun-1974 | 34(327) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Paul Tupai | Bedford Blues | Samoa | 16-Sep-1974 | 34(222) |
| 28-Mar-2009 | Ian Shuttleworth | Otley | England | 15-Jan-1975 | 34(73) |
| 05-Oct-2008 | Justin Bishop | Doncaster Knights | Ireland | 08-Nov-1974 | 33(332) |
| 25-Apr-2009 |  Heino Senekal | Cornish Pirates | Namibia | 20-Oct-1975 | 33(188) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Dan Hyde | Otley | England | 06-Jan-1976 | 33(96) |
| 11-Oct-2008 | Dan Parkes | Exeter Chiefs | England | 14-Aug-1975 | 33(59) |
| 21-Feb-2009 | Gerault Evans | Sedgley Park | Other | 30-Dec-1975 | 33(54) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Paul Williams | Otley | England | 06-Mar-1976 | 33(50) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Anton O'Donnell | Rotherham Titans | Ireland | 14-Mar-1976 | 33(42) |
| 02-May-2009 |  Andy Binns | Moseley | England | 29-Jun-1976 | 32(307) |
| 29-Apr-2009 | James Owen | Plymouth Albion | England | 28-Jun-1976 | 32(305) |
| 25-Apr-2009 |  Timothy Tunnicliffe | Esher | England | 10-Jul-1976 | 32(289) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Emyr Lewis | Exeter Chiefs | Wales | 21-Jul-1976 | 32(278) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Fosi Palaamo | Leeds Tykes | Samoa | 23-Aug-1976 | 32(245) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Gregor Hayter | Rotherham Titans | Scotland | 13-Aug-1976 | 32(241) |
| 29-Mar-2009 | Rob Rawlinson | Leeds Tykes | England | 23-Aug-1976 | 32(218) |
| 29-Nov-2008 | Keni Fisilau | Plymouth Albion | Tonga | 04-May-1976 | 32(209) |
| 30-Aug-2008 | Andy Craig | Sedgley Park | Scotland | 16-Mar-1976 | 32(167) |
| 02-May-2009 |  James Storey | London Welsh | Wales | 26-Nov-1976 | 32(157) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Sam Blythe | Exeter Chiefs | England | 17-Nov-1976 | 32(145) |
| 11-Apr-2009 | Donovan van Vuuren | Doncaster Knights | Other | 06-Jan-1977 | 32(95) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Aisea Havili | Cornish Pirates | Tonga | 11-Mar-1977 | 32(45) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Colm Hannon | Esher | England | 05-Apr-1977 | 32(20) |
| 31-Jan-2009 | Andy Brown | Otley | England | 17-Jan-1977 | 32(14) |
| 13-Dec-2008 | Simon Goldsmith | Esher | England | 15-Jan-1977 | 31(332) |
| 25-Apr-2009 |  Joe Clark | Newbury | England | 03-Jun-1977 | 31(326) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Kurt Johnson | Coventry | England | 23-Jun-1977 | 31(307) |
| 02-May-2009 | Paul Sampson | London Welsh | England | 12-Jul-1977 | 31(294) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Tony Yapp | Exeter Chiefs | England | 26-Jul-1977 | 31(273) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Louis McGowan | Rotherham Titans | England | 17-Oct-1977 | 31(191) |
| 18-Apr-2009 | Stephen Ward | Exeter Chiefs | England | 16-Oct-1977 | 31(184) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Dorian Williams | London Welsh | Wales | 10-Nov-1977 | 31(167) |
| 28-Feb-2009 | Tom Barlow | Rotherham Titans | England | 28-Sep-1977 | 31(154) |
| 25-Apr-2009 | Alan Paver | Cornish Pirates | England | 28-Nov-1977 | 31(149) |
| 29-Mar-2009 | Steve Winn | Cornish Pirates | Wales | 06-Nov-1977 | 31(144) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date of birth,
A(D) = Age(days).