| MD | Players | Club | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24-Mar-2012 |  Iain Taylor | Macclesfield | England | 05-Mar-1967 | 45(20) |
| 19-Feb-2022 |  James Shanahan | Blackheath | England | 12-Feb-1977 | 45(7) |
| 08-May-2010 |  Andrew Deacon | Cinderford | England | 31-Jul-1965 | 44(281) |
| 27-Apr-2019 |  Maama Molitika | Ampthill | Tonga | 26-Aug-1974 | 44(244) |
| 08-Feb-2014 |  Neil Dickinson | Wharfedale | England | 30-Jul-1969 | 44(193) |
| 01-Mar-2008 |  Neil Douch | Redruth | England | 15-Dec-1963 | 44(77) |
| 11-Mar-2000 | Jeff Probyn | Blackheath | England | 27-Apr-1956 | 43(319) |
| 21-Apr-2012 |  Ngazu Tau | Birmingham Solihull | Tonga | 15-Jan-1969 | 43(97) |
| 27-Apr-2019 | Kenni Barrett | Ampthill | England | 10-Apr-1976 | 43(17) |
| 06-Apr-2002 |  Graham Dawe | Plymouth Albion | England | 04-Sep-1959 | 42(215) |
| 27-Feb-2016 | Des Brett | Blackheath | England | 01-Aug-1973 | 42(210) |
| 29-Jan-2005 |  Kevin Wirachowski | Moseley | Canada | 02-Dec-1962 | 42(59) |
| 28-Apr-2001 | Steve Rigby | Fylde | England | 05-May-1959 | 41(359) |
| 18-Mar-2023 | Latu Makaafi | Hull | Tonga | 17-Aug-1981 | 41(213) |
| 21-Apr-2001 |  Paul Turner | Rugby Lions | Wales | 13-Feb-1960 | 41(68) |
| 27-Apr-2019 | Aleki Lutui | Ampthill | Tonga | 01-Jul-1978 | 40(300) |
| 31-Mar-2012 |  Jim Jenner | Stourbridge | England | 27-Nov-1971 | 40(125) |
| 26-Apr-2003 | Alan Yates | Fylde | England | 05-Jan-1963 | 40(111) |
| 30-Apr-2016 | Andrew Hodgson | Wharfedale | England | 09-Feb-1976 | 40(81) |
| 09-Apr-2022 | Soane Tonga'uiha | Chinnor | Tonga | 21-Jan-1982 | 40(78) |
| 26-Apr-2014 |  Kris Chesney | Esher | England | 02-Mar-1974 | 40(55) |
| 29-Apr-2017 |  Stephen Johnson | Hull Ionians | England | 07-Mar-1977 | 40(53) |
| 26-Apr-2014 |  Glen Kenworthy | Doncaster Knights | England | 15-Mar-1974 | 40(42) |
| 22-Sep-2012 |  Jon Phillips | Old Albanian | England | 16-Aug-1972 | 40(37) |
| 04-Nov-2017 | Louis McGowan | Caldy | England | 17-Oct-1977 | 40(18) |
| 22-Oct-2022 | Wayne Sprangle | Taunton | England | 28-Oct-1982 | 39(360) |
| 22-Dec-2018 | Paino Hehea | Ampthill | Tonga | 02-Jan-1979 | 39(355) |
| 21-Oct-2017 | Lawrence White | Old Albanian | England | 29-Nov-1977 | 39(327) |
| 04-May-2013 |  Matt Alcock | Sedgley Park | England | 17-Jul-1973 | 39(292) |
| 27-Apr-2019 | James Pritchard | Ampthill | Canada | 21-Jul-1979 | 39(281) |
| 27-Apr-2019 | Michael Penn | Moseley | England | 07-Aug-1979 | 39(264) |
| 18-Apr-2015 | Chris Fortey | Hartpury College | England | 25-Aug-1975 | 39(237) |
| 30-Apr-2022 | Gary Kingdom | Taunton | England | 02-Nov-1982 | 39(180) |
| 18-Jan-2003 |  Mike Healey | Kendal | Other | 28-Jul-1963 | 39(175) |
| 03-Mar-2012 |  Mark Lock | Rosslyn Park | England | 22-Sep-1972 | 39(163) |
| 18-Mar-2023 | James Tideswell | Moseley | England | 06-Nov-1983 | 39(133) |
| 25-Jan-2014 | Darren Morris | Doncaster Knights | Wales | 24-Sep-1974 | 39(124) |
| 15-Mar-2008 |  Howard Graham | Nuneaton | England | 23-Jan-1969 | 39(52) |
| 02-May-2009 |  David Guthrie | Blaydon | England | 24-Mar-1970 | 39(40) |
| 11-Jan-2020 | Kenneth Dowding | Richmond | England | 17-Dec-1980 | 39(25) |
| 01-Feb-2020 | JP Nel | Bishops Stortford | South Africa | 09-Jan-1981 | 39(23) |
| 19-Apr-2008 | Adrian Olver | Stourbridge | England | 02-Jun-1969 | 38(322) |
| 19-Feb-2005 | Darren Garforth | Nuneaton | England | 09-Apr-1966 | 38(317) |
| 01-Sep-2018 | Danny Brown | Darlington MP | Other | 08-Nov-1979 | 38(298) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date of birth,
A(D) = Age(days).